We Pick NHL Award Winners for Hurricanes
A day or two ago, James Mirtle asked who we would nominate from the Hurricanes for each of the major NHL Awards this season. Our "blogger in chief" then compiled each of the selections from all of the SBN Bloggers, and posted them on his site. He now has a list of nominees for all 30 NHL clubs. It's a very interesting read, to say the least.
Cory and I felt that before we discussed the article here at Canes Country, we would prepare the reasoning behind our choices. Surprisingly, we were both on the same page with our picks.
Here were our nominees:
Hart: Ray Whitney
Norris: Joni Pitkanen
Vezina: Cam Ward
Calder: Brandon Sutter
Selke: Eric Staal
This is what Cory had to say about his selections:
Hart: Ray Whitney — When Eric Staal, Rod Brind'Amour and Cam Ward all went through their rough patches this year, there was one constant: the play of Whitney. He's made big and clutch plays all year and has been an important veteran voice through it all. He's also limited his stick infractions this season.
Norris: Joni Pitkanen — This was tough ... you could make an argument for Joe Corvo or Anton Babchuk as well. But no one has put together a more complete, start-to-finish performance as Pitkanen. He rarely makes a dynamic pass or booms a slapshot, but makes the smart play nearly every time and has been way better than advertised in his own end.
Vezina: Cam Ward — He's had arguably the best season in franchise history. Enough said.
Calder: Brandon Sutter — There weren't many choices here, and while Sutter's role diminished to the point he was assigned to the AHL, he still showed flashes of growing into an all-around threat down the road.
Selke: Eric Staal — A part of Staal's game that is often overlooked and constantly improving, his defensive play has been a constant even when he's struggled in the offensive end. While his penalty killing opportunities have been somewhat limited, he's excelled when given the chance. He's an underrated defensive zone player who uses his speed and reach to effectively backcheck and neutralize opponents.
And here is the explanation behind my choices:
Hart: Ray Whitney -- As Cory said, Whitney has been the most consistent player throughout the entire year for the team. He has played on different lines and made others around him better. One of the few natural playmakers on the team, his 50 assists leads the team by a landslide. Plus, he has led the club in total points most of the season. Last but not least, his veteran presence and leadership ability is vital to the dressing room.
Selke: Joni Pitkanen-- Joe Corvo was right up there as well, but I believe Pitkanen has been a bit more consistent in his own end. He leads the team with "time on ice" for good reason, they miss him when he is not out there. His puck handling is grade A and passing is nearly the best on the team. He also is great at breaking up plays coming at him. I believe his partnership with Babchuk has helped the youngster's development. Finally, his (+12) versus Corvo's (+3) makes the decision a bit easier.
Vezina: Cam Ward-- Team record in wins. Career best save percentage and GAA. Nothing else needs to be said.
Calder: Brandon Sutter-- At times earlier in the year, Sutter looked like one of the best players on the ice. Not many choices here, so I will stick with this one.
Selke: Eric Staal-- Staal is usually matched up against the best players in the NHL, night in and night out. He has picked up his intensity in his own end, especially in the second half of the season and is a true force to play against. He is tied for the best plus/minus on the team with (+15). I can't think of a better choice in Carolina.
Do you agree or disagree?
15 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
It’s hard to argue with those choices. Whitney continues to quietly and consistently rack up points. Only twice in his career has he earned more assists than he has this season, and with three games left, he might reach a career high in that category this year.
It’s a really tough choice for Norris, because both Corvo and Pitkanen have improved in their own end while continuing to provide offense.
What about the Masterton and Lady Byng trophies? The Masterton would definitely go to Brind’Amour. I don’t know who would get the Lady Byng (Cam Ward?), but I know who definitely wouldn’t get it: LaRose, Ruutu, Gleason, Walker, Conboy… I know it takes more than staying out of the penalty box to be considered “gentlemanly,” but Joe Corvo only has 16 penalty minutes all season. That’s the least PIMs of all Hurricanes regulars.
I’d pick Cullen for Lady Byng, personally.
CanesCountry.com: An Eye On Carolina Hockey
by Cory Lavalette on Apr 9, 2009 9:13 AM EDT up reply actions
Oh no…. Lady Byng goes to Tim Conboy ;-)
by Mateos_Canes_Lamp on Apr 9, 2009 9:44 AM EDT up reply actions
I’d go Corvo over Pitkanen, he’s more dynamic and his transition game gets overlooked. His +/- took a hit during the rough patch 2 months ago when his forwards werent getting back on the play consequently leaving him hung out to dry.
Staal for the Selke? No doubt he’s improved and his reach is a huge asset defensively but he still drops a gear when his team doesnt have possession. The Selke for me, goes to a player who goes full speed when his team doesnt have the puck, is sound positionally with great hockey sense and instincts. No player jumps out at me, so I’ll go with Cole. Always backchecks, great positioning and instincts in the D-zone and wins the majority of loose puck battles.
I’m almost tempted to go with Pitkanen for the Selke seeing the amount of time he spends deep in the offensive zone. Adding to my comments about Staal, he still has a tendency to cheat in the D-zone, using his reach to poke check and hoping for the turnover and at the same time going into offensive mode. A great defensive forward would assure that no advantage is given to the opposition by taking the body first and foremost.
Who will score first for the ’Canes? Ruutu
Who will be called for the first penalty for the ’Canes? Wallin
Who will be credited with the most hits for the ’Canes? Cole
Who will be credited with the most takeaways for the ’Canes? Staal
Guess the winning team and the final score? ’Canes 13-3
I felt like I needed to get that out of my system…..
by Mateos_Canes_Lamp on Apr 9, 2009 11:01 AM EDT reply actions
All the points made about Whitney are true , but ……… for my money the team MVP is
Staal. He plays against the opposition top line and top D every night. Kills penalties
and plays on the PP. Logs heavy minutes, especially for a forward. Plays well in “big”
games.
Some of his struggles this year reflect the ’Canes inability to replace Cole with another forward with speed. Samsonov was not the answer.
Staal is the best player on the team …
I think the fact that Staal is up against the top lines every night, and still has a great +/- shows his improvement. Even more importantly, it seems that unlike in seasons past, Staal is getting the better of his peers when he faces the big guys, like Crosby/Malkin, Ovechkin, etc….
Last year or the year before that, he might have struggled in those matchups, but now he is looking like the best player on the ice no matter what. Maybe I am remembering things incorrectly, but that is an improvement that I have seen.
Ruutu - MVP (most versatile player)
I am not going to argue that Ruutu deserves the Hart over Staal or Whitney, he just doesn’t put up the numbers (not that he can’t though). But you really can’t overlook his consistency and versatility. LW, RW, 1st line, 3rd line, PP – he can play anywhere and at any time of the game. He NEVER takes a night off (and I can’t say that for some other ‘Canes mentioned for the Hart). He’ll check anyone, take a beating in front of the net, and never seems to get hurt. He also has some of the quickest hands on the team. He’s not your typical Hart candidate, but if they had a trophy for most versatile…Ruutu would win it hands down.
don’t forget he can play center, too. But the “never seems to get hurt” part is tough to use as a reason. Ruutu’s biggest problems prior to this season was his inability to stay healthy.
CanesCountry.com: An Eye On Carolina Hockey
by Cory Lavalette on Apr 9, 2009 12:12 PM EDT up reply actions
Andrew Ladd
The Blackhawks blog picked Ladd for the Selke……good for him. Glad to see he’s being recognized for a good season.
Hart Trophy
Wardo gets my pick for the Hart trophy. If you take him out of the mix, we are not where we are now. I don’t think the same can be said of any other single player on the team.






















