Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Dissecting Nick Diaz's Positive Drug Test

NHL Offseason Winners & Losers: Western Conference

A few weeks ago we looked at the best and worst free agent, trade and draft moves of the Eastern Conference's three divisions. It's time to head out West and access the offseason that was in the Central, Northwest and Pacific divisions.

CENTRAL DIVISION

Free Agency

Best Move: Detroit added Jason Williams ($1.5 million), Todd Bertuzzi ($1.5 million) and Patrick Eaves ($500,000) on one-year deals. Those are pretty low-risk, high-reward moves for a team with a tight cap situation.

Worst Move: Take your pick out of Chicago: blowing the RFA qualifying offers to Kris Versteeg and Cam Barker and having to pay them big bucks sooner than they needed to, or signing an injured Marian Hossa to a 12-year deal when they need to get both Jonathan Toews and Patrick Kane re-signed following the 2009-10 season. They should fire their GM ..... oh.

Star-divide

Trade Market

Nothing to see here. 

Entry Draft

Best Draft: Nashville — Detroit's trio of Landon Ferraro, Tomas Tatar and Andrej Nestrasil is impressive given they were taken at Nos. 32, 60 and 75, respectively, but the Preds takes top honors here. They further bolstered their blueline with dynamic power play quarterback Ryan Ellis, plus drafted Zach Budish and Charles-Olivier Roussel in the second round and Michael Latta with their second pick of the third. In all, they used 10 picks in the draft. 

NORTHWEST DIVISION

Free Agency 

Best Move: Yes, the Flames landed Jay Bouwmeester (see below), but their best free agency signing was the bargain-basement addition of defensive specialist Fredrik Sjostrom. At $750,000 a year for two seasons, Sjostrom will help the Flames PK and perhaps get a chance to fill a bigger role on the top-heavy Calgary front lines.

Worst Move: Edmonton shored up their goaltending issues by signing veteran Nikolai Khabibulin, but giving a 36-year-old with a history of injuries a four-year, $15 million contract  — which will be on the cap even if he has to retire before the deal is up — came off as desperate, especially for a team that's a ways from seriously contending.

Trade Market

Best Move: Calgary's acquisition of the rights to Jay Bouwmeester (for Jordan Leopold, who was also an RFA, and a third-round pick) gave GM Darryl Sutter the jump on negotiating with the the gem of the 2009 free agent class. Yes, the price was steep and the need was questionable, but Sutter clearly wanted Jay-Bo and got him because he was willing to pay a price to talk to him before anyone else. Honorable mention to the Canucks for taking advantage of San Jose's cap mess and getting d-men Christian Erhoff and Brad Lukowich for next to nothing.

Worst Move: First Joe Sakic retires, then the Avs deal Ryan Smyth to Los Angeles for a fifth-rounder and couple OK defensemen in Kyle Quincey and Tom Preissing. Yes, Smyth's $7 million-plus salary was a burden, but right now there is no proven face to the Colorado franchise — except maybe Paul Stastny — and only a couple pieces in what will be a long rebuild. 

Entry Draft

Best Draft: Colorado — Yep, things look bad in the short term in the Mile High City, but this year's draft looks like a good start. Some think third-overall pick Matt Duchene might wind up being the best player in a draft hyped as the Tavares/Hedman sweepstakes. Tack on Ryan O'Reilly, Stefan Elliott and Tyson Barrie — all chosen by No. 63 — plus looking for an answer in net by picking two goalies in the late rounds, and the Avalanche have something to look forward to.

PACIFIC DIVISION

Free Agency

Best Move: There weren't many good moves made in the Pacific, but any time you can add a guy named Vernon Fiddler to your lineup, I'm on board. Well done, 'Yotes. Now if someone would bring back Epsen Knutsen.

Worst Move: I like Rob Scuderi just fine. Just not $3.4 million for four years fine, which is what the Kings gave him this offseason. With hot shots like Drew Doughty, Jack Johnson, Thomas Hickey and Colten Teubert all either with Los Angeles or on their way, the move seems short sighted and overly extravagant. 

Trade Market

Best Move: It stinks to lose Chris Pronger — regardless what you think of him — but the Ducks got the equivalent of three or four first-round picks for a player with one year left on his contract. Luca Sbisa will provide youth on the back end, while Joffrey Lupul is a legitimate top-nine forward. Throw in two firsts and a conditional third and Anaheim has kept themselves competitive in the now plus helped their future. 

Worst Move: The Coyotes must be desperate, because bringing back Radim Vrbata and his $3 million-a-year price tag certainly looks like it. For the next two years, they need to hope Vrbata looks like the 2007-08 version and not the one who skipped out on the Lightning after 18 games last season. The only good news they didn't give up much in David Hale and fist-absorber Todd Fedoruk.

Entry Draft

Best Draft: — The Ducks picked twice in the first and again at No. 37, but I wasn't thrilled with the two first-rounders (Peter Holland way up at No. 15, Kyle Palmieri at No. 26). But the rest of the Pacific was simply OK, so by default we'll give it to the team that stockpiled some picks and used them.

Comment 3 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

Good read Cory, thanks!! I liked the part about the Chi Hawks..oh!!

A

by Paladin6 on Sep 11, 2009 7:00 AM EDT reply actions  

What if

How would you rank the trade market for the West if the Heatley/Marleau/Frolov & Stoll deal goes down? It gives SJ more offense, but has that ever been a problem (I know, it did work pretty well for the Red Wings last season)? The Kings get veteran leadership, but isn’t Frolov and Stoll an awful lot to give up for the veteran leadership of a guy just stripped of his captaincy?

by C-Leaguer on Sep 11, 2009 10:40 AM EDT reply actions  

I’ve always liked Marleau … I think San Jose would be silly to move him. And L.A. would be silly to make the move, too. L.A.’s added too much wasted salary already, IMO. I like Scuderi and Smyth, but both are overpaid.

by Cory Lavalette on Sep 11, 2009 11:33 AM EDT reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to Canes Country, a hockey blog, information hub, and community center for fans of the Carolina Hurricanes.

FanPosts

Hockey and Local Twitter

Carolina Hurricanes Roster

# Pos. DOB W H
Bryan Allen 5 D 8/21/1980 226 6-5
Brian Boucher 33 G 1/2/1977 200 6-2
Drayson Bowman 21 C 3/8/1989 190 6-1
Tim Brent 37 C 3/10/1984 188 6-0
Patrick Dwyer 39 RW 6/22/1983 175 5-11
Justin Faulk 28 D 3/20/1992 205 6-0
Tim Gleason 6 D 1/29/1983 217 6-0
Jay Harrison 44 D 11/3/1982 211 6-4
Jussi Jokinen 36 LW 4/1/1983 198 5-11
Derek Joslin 27 D 3/17/1987 210 6-1
Chad LaRose 59 LW 3/27/1982 181 5-10
Jamie McBain 4 D 2/25/1988 200 6-2
Andreas Nodl 14 RW 2/28/1987 196 6-1
Justin Peters 60 G 8/30/1986 205 6-1
Joni Pitkanen 25 D 9/19/1983 210 6-3
Tuomo Ruutu 15 LW 2/16/1983 200 6-0
Jeff Skinner 53 RW 5/16/1992 193 5-11
Jaroslav Spacek 8 D 2/11/1974 210 6-0
Eric Staal 12 C 10/29/1984 205 6-4
Anthony Stewart 13 C 1/5/1985 230 6-3
Brandon Sutter 16 C 2/14/1989 183 6-3
Jiri Tlusty 19 C 3/16/1988 209 6-0
Cam Ward 30 G 2/29/1984 185 6-1

More great SB Nation Blogs

Tags


Managing Editor

Cc_shieldjpg_small Bob Wage

Editors

Cc_cory_small Cory Lavalette

Under_dawgs_jpeg_small Carolyn Christians

95e2a02d-007c-4379-a43d-8331eb2e0d40_small Brian LeBlanc

Contributors

Tuomo_twitter_profile_small Jamie Kellner

75120_1305100992932_1392720706_31336970_7465882_n_small C. Wilson Spiers

293608_10150264887072045_612857044_7969003_540721_n_small Lee Phillips