So, in our conversations on our various Eric Staal issues I posed a question that I thought would be interesting for everyone here to discuss.  Who would you rather have as captain:  Eric Staal today or Rod Brind'Amour from five years ago?  Why would you choose who you chose?  No chosing both.  Pick one or the other.  It sounds like a fun thought experiment to me and should generate some interesting dicsussion (and hopefully not just some re-hashing of old discussion).  Have at it!