clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Canes Country Clash, Round One - Pacific Division Results

New, comments

Cory and I were thinking that since there were two of us writing now, perhaps it would be fun to occasionally have a debate, or a "point/counterpoint" feature for the blog. We decided to start this new feature off by speculating how each team in the league will finish in their respective divisions. The plan is to have one of these features each week.

While the rest of the NHL seems to be at a stand-still waiting on that svelte Swede, Mats Sundin to make a decision, we aren't going to wait around for him to sign a contract before we make bold predictions. (But we reserve the right to change our minds after he signs somewhere.)

Let's begin with the Pacific Division-


  1. Anaheim

  2. San Jose

  3. Dallas

  4. Phoenix

  5. Los Angeles


  1. Dallas

  2. San Jose

  3. Anaheim

  4. Phoenix

  5. Los Angeles


For the past few years, the top teams have been Dallas, San Jose, and Anaheim. Nothing really has happened during the offseason to make me think that any those teams won't dominate again this year. The hardest part is deciding which of the three will win the division. My pick is Anaheim.

The team is loaded on offense and defense plus has a proven vet in goal. Corey Perry quietly scored 29 goals in just 70 games last year and is now a year older and wiser. Ryan Getzlaf and Chris Kunitz are horses. The addition of Brendan Morrison is a nice bonus, while the deduction of Bertuzzi is addition by subtraction. They will have the services of Scott Niedermayer from the beginning of the year this time around, which can't hurt. They also have one of the top coaches in the league with Randy Carlyle. There are still some unresolved issues regarding the possible trading of Mathieu Schneider and re-signing of Teemu Selanne, but Brian Burke will have the Ducks loaded for bear come October.

San Jose should come in second, but in my mind they have more questions than answers at this point. They fired Ron Wilson and brought in Todd McLellan. Will that help or hurt? Brian Campbell is gone and Dan Boyle and Rob Blake are in his stead. Boyle is no Campbell and Blake is past his prime. How much does Blake have left in the tank? Patrick Marleau is talented but is questionable as a captain in my book. (I haven't forgotten about him jumping out of the way of a scoring puck in the playoffs.) Maybe if he decides to start blocking a few shots, this team can move on in the playoffs? I can't help but feel that as long as he is wearing the "C", it's close but no cigar for this bunch.

Dallas has a very good team and was able to build up some momentum in the playoffs last year. Will they be able to capitalize? Brad Richards is huge for these guys as is Brendan Morrow. But Mike Modano keeps getting older. The addition of Sean Avery is interesting, but he isn't going to win any championships by sucker punching opponents and baiting goalies. Dallas comes in third.

Phoenix looks like they will be fun to watch this year and could be a sleeper team. They are loaded with young talent and have a big Russian body in goal, 6'3 Ilya Bryzgalov who can steal some games all by himself. Derek Morris and Eddie "Jovocop" Jovanovski are among the blueliners and Olli Jokinen is a talented player who can score goals. I look for Kyle Turris and Peter Mueller to have huge years. Will they be good enough to carry the Coyotes to the playoffs? I wouldn't bet on it.

What can you say about Los Angeles other than huh?? They confused the heck out of me at the draft. For a team that already had a young superstar defenseman in Jack Johnson, they kept right on drafting more defensemen, one right after another. After choosing the best blueliner in the draft, Drew Doughty, they picked another bluechipper with their next pick Colton Teubert. And with their third pick, what did they do? You guessed it, they selected yet another defenseman, Viatcheslav Voynov. How many young defensemen does one team need? Then they traded their best defenseman, Lubomir Visnovski to Edmonton for two role players, Matt Greene and Jarret Stoll. I guess it's no secret what they are doing, they're getting into position for the Johnny Tavares sweepstakes. Someone should tell them that Tavares is not a defenseman.


The Pacific may be the league's toughest division. It was the only division with two 100-point teams last season (San Jose with 108, Anaheim with 102) and third place Dallas had 97 points and reached the Western Conference final. Given the confidence boost they received from their playoff run and the upgrades in the roster, I'm going with the Stars.

The Stars, from top to bottom, have a blend of youth, experience, grit and finesse that any team would admire. Need to play a smash-mouth style? Call on captain Brenden Morrow or spark plug Stephane Robidas. Want to get under your opponent's skin? Steve Ott is a super pest, and there's none better than newcomer Sean Avery. Want to dazzle your foe? Centers Mike Ribiero, Brad Richards and Mike Modano, and defenseman Sergei Zubov are all programmed to amaze. Add the defensive acumen of Jere Lehtinen, an up-and-coming D corps consisting of Trevor Daley, Niklas Grossman, Matt Niskanen and Mark Fistric, Vezina-level netminder Marty Turco, and rookies Fabian Brunnstrom and James Neal, and you have a recipe for success.

Plain and simple, the Sharks needed to part ways with Ron Wilson. Wilson is a very good coach, but when he pinned the Sharks' 2006-07 playoff failures on captain Patrick Marleau — who was playing through a shoulder injury — he basically ended any chance San Jose would go further in 2007-08. They didn't, and he's gone. GM Doug Wilson brought in Detroit assistant Todd McLennan to lead the troops. If McLennan can get Marleau back to his point-per-game abilities, convince Joe Thornton to sometimes leave the perimeter, weave Dan Boyle and Rob Blake into a revamped blueline and get another huge season out of Evgeni Nabokov, the Sharks could become the league's best team. But even if he can't do all those things, the Sharks should again go into the playoffs as one of the Cup favorites.

The Ducks didn't change much this offseason, so if they're rested and healthy, they should again be one of the league's top teams. One big question mark is whether or not Teemu Selanne will come back for another season (again). Adding him to the right wing would move Todd Marchant back to the third line where he belongs and give new acquisition Brendan Morrison a weapon to feed the puck to. J-S Giguere can be counted on net, especially in the playoffs, and the defense still boasts three of the league's best in Chris Pronger, Scott Neidermayer and Mathieu Schneider, but all three aren't getting any younger. The window may be closing some for Anaheim, even though they have some bright young stars in Ryan Getzlaf and Corey Perry, so they must seize the moment in 2008-09.

Phoenix solidified their goaltending midseason by claiming Ilya Bryzgalov off waivers from the Ducks and immediately turned their season around. Some are listing the Coyotes as a playoff sleeper, but even though there's oodles of young skill, solid leadership from Shane Doan, and a new No. 1 center in Olli Jokinen, the Desert Dogs are still a year away from contending for the postseason. That doesn't mean don't watch! Peter Mueller was an overlooked phenom last season, and Kyle Turris and first-rounder Mikkel Boedker could play significant roles for coach Wayne Gretzky.

The Kings will be amazing — in about four years. This year? Probably not so amazing. But like Phoenix, there's plenty worth watching here. The second overall pick in this year's draft, d-man Drew Doughty, could join the team this season. Holdovers Anze Kopitar, Jack Johnson, Dustin Brown and Alexander Frolov are all young and exciting. But the goaltending depth is as thin as a fast food hamburger. L.A. is doing the right thing by bringing along future No. 1 Jonathan Bernier slowly, but the team's reluctance to add a veteran to bridge the gap will cripple their 2008-09 season. That being said, the Kings are still under the cap floor and need to add salary before the start of the year. Don't be surprised if, by the end of the preseason, Chicago lame duck goalie Nikolai Khabibulin is roaming the crease for Los Angeles. But even his addition doesn't mean anything to a team this young and inexperienced.



It looks like we agree that the Pacific will be tough and that the "Big Three" will be fighting it out to see who is best, we just disagree who will end up on top.

While I concur that Dallas has a very good team, I just can't see them being good enough to get over the hump. You have Mike Modano listed as a key player, but I think that he could very easily take a big step back this year. He had a great post-season, but sometimes it can be tough for an older player to bounce back after going hard in the playoffs. The back-up goaltending is questionable, (as it is for several teams). They will be good, but not good enough in my book.

You mention that ex-Sharks coach, Ron Wilson pinned San Jose's failure in the 2006-07 playoffs on Patrick Marleau, even as Marlaeu was playing with a shoulder injury. That is true, but whose fault was it last year and what kind of injury did the team captain have when he jumped out of the way of a shot that ended up going in the net? Maybe Wilson had a valid point, shoulder injury or not? Marleau is a huge talent, no doubt, but I can't see that team making it big with him being counted on to lead the way. The coach is unproven and overall leadership could be a problem. Regardless, the Sharks will certainly be in the mix.

I also agree that the Ducks will be pressing harder this year and that gives me another reason to think that they will come out on top in the Division. This season will probably be the last for Brian Burke in California. Another division championship would likely put a few more million in his next contract, (with the Leafs).

I think that we are in almost total agreement regarding the Coyotes, although I do believe they have a semi-legitimate shot to surprise people and make the playoffs. They have some experience to blend with the youth, but it all depends upon team chemistry. Perhaps I'll give them a slightly higher chance to make the post-season than you do.

You make a good point about Khabibulin and the Kings. The team still has salary cap money to spend because they are under the minimum cap. If a trade makes sense, I could see them acquiring the "Bulin Wall", but I agree that won't be enough to leverage them out of the Pacific cellar.

I'll let you have the last word.....


Well Bubba, I'm glad we're locked in on the bottom two, but we've definitely shuffled up the top of the heap.For me, Modano is a key player simply because he's now a third-line center,not a No. 1. We all know how important an above-average third-line pivot can be — see Matt Cullen during the Cup run — and I think we all agree Modano still has plenty of skill, even at his age. You're definitely right on the backup goaltending, though. Tobias Stephan strikes fear into no one. I fully expect an upgrade here at some point. It's crazy to think that at the start of 2006-07, Mike Smith and Dan Ellis battled in camp for the right to back up Turco. Now all three are starters and the Stars are left with a question mark behind Turco.

As for San Jose, I would pin all of Marleau's performance last year on Ron Wilson. I think he sucked the joy of the game right out of Captain Pat, which may have led to the obvious lackluster effort on the play you describe. Should a team's captain be derailed by something like a coach's criticism? Probably not, but even if Marleau isn't a great leader, it will be nice for them if they get back a 70- or 80-point Marleau instead of the 48-point guy from last year. I fully expect that to happen. All that being said, there's reason we both have them second instead of first: there's something missing in San Jose. Jeremy Roenick from 10 years ago would maybe get them over the hump, but he's just a role player now and can't be expected to lead the team in game-winning goals again (his 10 were second only to Alex Ovechkin's 11 last year). Maybe Rob Blake can find the an extra gear playing for a good team, but — like Roenick — it might be too late.

In Anaheim, I was on board with the "Brian Burke is a genius" school of thought for a season or two, but he's dried up the team's farm system (though they did have a pile of picks this past draft) and spent more time arguing with Kevin Lowe than trying to give his team a chance to remain on top. He let Selanne and Niedermayer hold him hostage all last year, and the Finnish Flash could cast his shadow of doubt again this season. Take Selanne, mix in Burke's uncertain future, and add an owner in trouble and I think there are too many off-ice distractions for the Ducks to overcome. This time next year everyone will probably be talking about how he's mapped out a rebuilding plan for the Leafs, but the more and more I look, the more and more I wonder: Was Kevin Lowe right? Does this guy build a short-term contender, then set sail for another team, leaving a shipwreck in his wake?

Only time will tell.


Anyone else have an opinion?